Iain MacWhirter - Disunited Kingdom: How Westminster Won
a Referendum but Lost Scotland
Award- winning Scottish journalist and political commentator for the
Herald Iain MacWhirter, has written
his second book on the Scottish Referendum 'Disunited Kingdom" How
Westminster won a Referendum but Lost Scotland".
writes that the SNP 167 pages indie light White Paper was pretty much the same as what
Regions in other federal states enjoy. We may say that there is a fine
line between Indie light and Federal states that pretty much run all their own
affairs. He argues that the Union has been presented as a partnership
of equals and of two nations joining together – as a moral union in 1707, which
has now been broken by the chancellor George Osborne.
MacWhirter takes a broad and informed view as an
insider of both Westminster and Holyrood politics. He also reported frequently
on the Scottish Referendum, in the Herald and Sunday Herald. His
first book was The Road to Referendum. He gave a talk at Edinburgh
book festival 2015 about how inspirational the whole Referendum process was
and how it engaged so many different voice
In MacWhirter’s view nationalism in Europe has now replaced class warfare. "Decline of industrial class politics and the rise of regionalism in Europe, nationalism is proving to be a new organising principle in democratic engagement."
He writes that, "Young people see independence as the only viable challenge to globalization and the dominance of neo liberalisation." Civic nationalism allows for a means of progressing the democratic process.
For him an independent Scotland would be a better society. There is a
huge democratic deficit between Scotland and England and are now on very
different paths. He argues that baby steps devolution is not workable and it
would be better from a position of implicit sovereignty strength through
independence to then remake the UK holistically. To then work to establish
new ground rules to work alongside the other UK nations. This is pretty much
the thinking that I believed with regard to Scotland and that federalism will
not be achievable through Westminster.
He has visited many other federal states to gather information on how their Federalism works. The Scottish Parliament is NOT the strongest devolved parliament in the world. Regions like Quebec or Alaska are practically independent as we in the UK would describe it. – they control ALL their taxes, economy, borrowing etc. Only foreign affairs and defence are shared.
had three main reasons for his decision to vote for Scottish Independence
reason was that England sees
little need for Federalism and seems happy with the Westminster system. The second was the SNP
White Paper (at 167 pages) of indie light – was in affect so light and safe,
how was it independence at all? So much would remain the same. Real Independence
statements are normally short ones......!
I agree -
playing it safe may have been the right thing five years ago - but now we need to
be more radical! Otherwise what's the
and most important reason, was Osborne's saying that Scotland
could not use its pound, while all those south of Hadrian's
Wall could. Even though the
two countries are big trading partners.
In his mind this broke the moral union.
I agree with
many of his arguments with some reservation. MacWhirter doesn’t feel that the UK is a
repressive state. In my view unless Labour politicians leave the House of Lords
– this is still a country of patronage, elitism and inequality. The UK is a
top-down hierarchy. The Land Reform Bill is also crucial too with the gross ownership of Scottish land by only a few.
Also at the Union
of the Parliaments there was a great deal of coercion placed on the Scottish
Parliament – historian Tom Devine writes that troops were positioned at the border
and in Northern Ireland, England also refused to trade with Scotland (Tom
Devine, The Scottish Nation). Most of Scotland
at the time was strongly opposed to the Union. Of course there were back then some advantages of the Union, as all the political elite left Edinburgh for London with James VI and his court! Which meant the great thinkers were free to have their discussions and we had the Scottish Enlightenment.
press appeared to believe that the SNP was about right wing thugs and attempted
to portray this in the media. Nothing could be further from the truth. The
grassroots indie campaign was energetic and inspired and led by articulate
artists, journalists, scientists and business people from all walks of life.
*MacWhirter presented Westminster Live for ten years before returning to Scotland in
1999 to present Holyrood Live in 1999. He wrote Road to Referendum.